diff --git a/source/components/ComparativeSimulation.js b/source/components/ComparativeSimulation.js
index 2eb60e7d3..9ebd8b07a 100644
--- a/source/components/ComparativeSimulation.js
+++ b/source/components/ComparativeSimulation.js
@@ -8,7 +8,8 @@ import ComparativeTargets from 'Components/ComparativeTargets'
 import './ComparativeSimulation.css'
 import {
 	nextStepsSelector,
-	analysisWithDefaultsSelector
+	analysisWithDefaultsSelector,
+	noUserInputSelector
 } from 'Selectors/analyseSelectors'
 import simulationConfig from './simulateur-rémunération-dirigeant.yaml'
 import { createMarkdownDiv } from 'Engine/marked'
@@ -18,7 +19,8 @@ export default compose(
 	connect(state => ({
 		previousAnswers: state.conversationSteps.foldedSteps,
 		noNextSteps: nextStepsSelector(state, simulationConfig).length == 0,
-		analyses: analysisWithDefaultsSelector(state, simulationConfig)
+		analyses: analysisWithDefaultsSelector(state, simulationConfig),
+		noUserInput: noUserInputSelector(state)
 	}))
 )(
 	class extends React.Component {
@@ -26,7 +28,13 @@ export default compose(
 			displayAnswers: false
 		}
 		render() {
-			let { colours, noNextSteps, previousAnswers, analyses } = this.props
+			let {
+				colours,
+				noNextSteps,
+				previousAnswers,
+				analyses,
+				noUserInput
+			} = this.props
 
 			return (
 				<div id="ComparativeSimulation" className="ui__ container">
@@ -58,7 +66,8 @@ export default compose(
 								<p>Vous avez atteint l'estimation la plus précise.</p>
 							</>
 						)}
-						<ComparativeTargets />
+
+						<ComparativeTargets hide={noUserInput} />
 					</div>
 				</div>
 			)
diff --git a/source/components/ComparativeTargets.js b/source/components/ComparativeTargets.js
index 41eb19f39..caa55187f 100644
--- a/source/components/ComparativeTargets.js
+++ b/source/components/ComparativeTargets.js
@@ -41,10 +41,12 @@ export default compose(
 				analyses,
 				target,
 				setSituationBranch,
-				chiffreAffaires
+				chiffreAffaires,
+				hide
 			} = this.props
+			console.log(hide)
 			return (
-				<div id="targets">
+				<div id="targets" style={{ display: hide ? 'none' : 'block' }}>
 					<h3>{target.title}</h3>
 					<PeriodSwitch />
 					<ul>
diff --git a/source/selectors/analyseSelectors.js b/source/selectors/analyseSelectors.js
index 8afb6b49a..48eb20573 100644
--- a/source/selectors/analyseSelectors.js
+++ b/source/selectors/analyseSelectors.js
@@ -23,7 +23,8 @@ import {
 	isEmpty,
 	pick,
 	reduce,
-	intersection
+	intersection,
+	dissoc
 } from 'ramda'
 import { getFormValues } from 'redux-form'
 import { createSelector, createSelectorCreator, defaultMemoize } from 'reselect'
@@ -63,7 +64,10 @@ export let situationSelector = createDeepEqualSelector(
 
 export let noUserInputSelector = createSelector(
 	[situationSelector],
-	situation => !situation || isEmpty(situation)
+	situation =>
+		!situation ||
+		console.log(situation) ||
+		isEmpty(dissoc('période', situation))
 )
 
 export let formattedSituationSelector = createSelector(